Montauk Yacht Club
Third band: properties that pass the EMPTYJET luxury gate but with fewer or narrower references. Still a deliberate selection, not a directory.
334 guest reviews analysed
32 Star Island Road, Montauk, NY, 11954, US
Distinctions
Card travel programme
EMPTYJET Consensus
73.4 / 100
Our own composite of guest reviews across Google, Tripadvisor, Booking, Agoda and every major platform — the praise and the complaints.
Analysed from 334 guest reviews across Booking.com, Tripadvisor and Trip.com.
Most noted: noise.
Best for
- families
- beach
- couples
- food & wine
About Montauk Yacht Club
Montauk Yacht Club is a waterfront hotel in Montauk with 111 rooms, a full-service marina and a private beach exclusively for hotel guests. The property has three pools, a spa called The Wellness Cabana by ELEMIS and a fitness programme that includes seasonal yoga and fitness classes.
Dining includes Alba Spiaggia, an Italian waterfront restaurant, plus a Pool Bar. On-site activities and services include a kids club with a full calendar, yacht charters and slips, tennis and padel at a renovated racquet centre, and complimentary Linus bikes.
Why it stands out
EMPTYJET property with a waterfront marina, private beach and 111 rooms. Listed as 4 stars and part of American Express Fine Hotels + Resorts for 2025, the hotel combines spa, multiple pools, dining and family programming.
Key facts
- Keys
- 111 rooms
- Check-in / out
- 16:00 / 11:00
- Children
- full calendar of kids programming
- Type
- Beach, Island
Amenities
Verified 22 Aug 2026Activities
- Private beach — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Private Beach (Exclusively for Hotel Guests)
- Swimming pool — three pools
- Tennis — evidence: fully renovated racquet center for padel and tennis
- Padel — evidence: fully renovated racquet center for padel and tennis
- Yacht marina — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Full-Service Marina — The Hamptons' Largest (Day Boats to 300-ft Superyachts)
- Cycling — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Complimentary Linus Bikes (Available 7AM–7PM via Front Desk)
Dining
- Fine dining — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Alba Spiaggia — Italian Waterfront Restaurant
- Bar — Everything feels better poolside, especially when paired with locally sourced bites and refreshing afternoon cocktails
Family
- Kids club — evidence: full calendar of kids programming
Location
- Historic building — JSON-LD amenityFeature: 5 Historic 1928 Cottages with Private Patio or Balcony
Services
- Yacht charter — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Safe Harbor Montauk Yacht Club — Slips, Charters, Fishing Trips, Sunset Cruises
Wellness
- Spa — The Wellness Cabana by ELEMIS, expanded wellness offerings
- Fitness centre — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Seasonal Yoga & Fitness Classes On Property
Dining
Verified 22 Aug 2026Spa & wellness
Verified 22 Aug 2026Services
Verified 22 Aug 2026Awards & affiliations
Location
41.0693, -71.9325Sources+
- Official hotel websiteOfficial17 fields
- WikidataEncyclopedia1 field