FirstSuites Score 8.95 out of 10, EMPTYJET 5★
Aman New York
New York · United States
84.0EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$from ~$445 / night
- City
- Wellness
- Urban resort
EMPTYJET rank #298
The Fifth Avenue Hotel
FirstSuites Score
8.63 / 10
10.00 = a flawless five-star; above it, the sixth and seventh stars.
1 W 28th St, New York, NY, 10001, US
Distinctions
Hotel distinction
Forbes Travel Guide
Among the world's finest
Advisor network
Card travel programme
EMPTYJET Consensus
91.4 / 100
Our own composite of guest reviews across Google, Tripadvisor, Booking, Agoda and every major platform — the praise and the complaints.
EMPTYJET 5-starEMPTYJET 5-star
Analysed from 9,044 guest reviews across Tripadvisor, Google, Trip.com and Booking.com.
Most noted: rooms.
Best for
- city breaks
- food & wine
- business
- couples
About The Fifth Avenue Hotel
The Fifth Avenue Hotel holds an EMPTYJET 5-star designation and a 5-star rating in Manhattan, New York. Guests can experience fine dining at Café Carmellini, which serves American cuisine, and enjoy drinks at The Portrait Bar, known for its collection of artwork. The hotel provides accessible guestrooms, a fitness centre, and a thoughtful concierge service. Pet-friendly policies are in place for guests traveling with animals. The property has been recognised on The World's 50 Best Hotels 2025 list at rank 75 and is Forbes Travel Guide Recommended for 2026.
Why it stands out
The Fifth Avenue Hotel is listed for its EMPTYJET 5-star status, 5-star classification, and recognition on The World's 50 Best Hotels 2025 list at rank 75. Its Manhattan location, fine dining at Café Carmellini, and Forbes Travel Guide Recommended rating further support its inclusion.
Key facts
- Official classification
- 5-star (google_maps)
- Check-in / out
- 12:00 / 15:00
- Pets
- not_allowed
- Architecture
- Combining a restored Gilded Age mansion with a contemporary tower
- Type
- City
Amenities
Verified 19 Aug 2026Accessibility
- Accessible rooms — evidence: Accessible guestrooms are available
Dining
- Fine dining — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Restaurant
- Bar — The Portrait Bar, named for the exceptional collection of artwork that adorns its wood-paneled walls
Policies
- Pet friendly — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Pet Friendly
Services
- Concierge — evidence: thoughtful concierge service
Wellness
- Fitness centre — JSON-LD amenityFeature: Fitness Center
Dining
Verified 19 Aug 2026Awards & affiliations
- The World's 50 Best HotelsList · #752025
- MICHELIN GuideTwo Keys2025
- Forbes Travel GuideRecommended2026
- American ExpressFine Hotels + Resorts
- VirtuosoMember
- American Express Fine Hotels + Resorts
Location
40.7450, -73.9877Sources+
- EMPTYJET seed catalogueSeed4 fields
- Official hotel websiteOfficial13 fields
- Serper (Google Maps data)Places provider6 fields
- WikidataEncyclopedia1 field
Collections
More in New York
View allAman New York Warren Street Hotel 
FirstSuites Score 8.95 out of 10, EMPTYJET 5★Warren Street Hotel
New York · United States
93.0EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$$from ~$949 / night- City
- Wellness
- Design
The Greenwich Hotel 
EMPTYJET RecommendThe Greenwich Hotel
New York · United States
92.6EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$$$from ~$1,823 / night- City
- city breaks
- business
The Mark 
EMPTYJET RecommendThe Mark
New York · United States
73.8EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$$$from ~$1,985 / night- City
- city breaks
- food & wine
The Carlyle 
EMPTYJET RecommendThe Carlyle
New York · United States
86.0EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$$$from ~$2,039 / night- City
- Wellness
- city breaks
The Peninsula New York 
EMPTYJET ApprovedThe Peninsula New York
New York · United States
80.4EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$$from ~$1,459 / night- City
- city breaks
- business