EMPTYJET Recommend
Cheeca Lodge and Spa
Islamorada · United States
66.9EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$from ~$226 / night
- Beach
- Golf
- Wellness
EMPTYJET RecommendEMPTYJET rank #2536
Amara Cay Resort
Second band: well-established luxury properties with consistent evidence across independent references.
5,039 guest reviews analysed
80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL, 33036, USA
Distinctions
Card travel programme
EMPTYJET Consensus
71.0 / 100
Our own composite of guest reviews across Google, Tripadvisor, Booking, Agoda and every major platform — the praise and the complaints.
Analysed from 5,039 guest reviews across Tripadvisor, Google, Booking.com, Trip.com and Priceline.
Most noted: rooms.
Best for
- families
- couples
- beach
- adventure
About Amara Cay Resort
Amara Cay Resort sits in Islamorada, United States, and is recognised as an EMPTYJET property. The resort features direct beach access, allowing guests to enjoy activities on the water or relax by the shore. There are five pools shared across three resorts, along with a poolside Tiki Bar offering cocktails and ocean breezes. Dining options include the ReelCatch restaurant, serving island-inspired flavours.
The combination of multiple pools, beach access, and casual dining makes Amara Cay Resort a versatile option for a Florida Keys getaway. The property provides both leisure and adventure opportunities in a precise Islamorada location.
Why it stands out
Amara Cay Resort is listed for its EMPTYJET status, exact Islamorada location, and strong leisure offering. Beach access, five pools, and dining options such as ReelCatch and the Tiki Bar highlight its appeal for a relaxed or active stay in the Florida Keys.
Key facts
- Official classification
- 4-star (google_maps)
- Type
- Beach
Amenities
Verified 19 Aug 2026Activities
- Beach access — Spend a day on the water full of adventure, or lounge on the beach
- Swimming pool — Three Resorts with Five Pools & Beaches
Dining
- Bar — Chill out with refreshing cocktails and ocean breezes at the poolside Tiki Bar
Dining
Verified 19 Aug 2026Beach
Verified 19 Aug 2026Services
Verified 19 Aug 2026Awards & affiliations
- American ExpressThe Hotel Collection
- American Express The Hotel Collection
Location
24.9001, -80.6573Sources+
- EMPTYJET seed catalogueSeed4 fields
- Official hotel websiteOfficial13 fields
- Serper (Google Maps data)Places provider2 fields
Collections
More in Islamorada
View allCheeca Lodge and Spa Islander Resort 
EMPTYJET RecommendIslander Resort
Islamorada · United States
84.1EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$from ~$345 / night- Beach
- Golf
- Family
Three Waters Resort and Marina, a Tribute Portfolio Resort EMPTYJET RecommendThree Waters Resort and Marina, a Tribute Portfolio Resort
Islamorada · United States
78.8EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100Price on request- couples
- families