EMPTYJET Recommend
Amara Cay Resort
Islamorada · United States
71.0EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$from ~$166 / night
- Beach
- families
- couples
EMPTYJET RecommendEMPTYJET rank #2963
Islander Resort
Second band: well-established luxury properties with consistent evidence across independent references.
4,415 guest reviews analysed
82100 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, 33036, USA
Distinctions
Card travel programme
EMPTYJET Consensus
84.1 / 100
Our own composite of guest reviews across Google, Tripadvisor, Booking, Agoda and every major platform — the praise and the complaints.
Analysed from 4,415 guest reviews across Google, Tripadvisor, Booking.com, Trip.com and Priceline.
Most noted: rooms.
Best for
- families
- couples
- beach
- golf
About Islander Resort
Islander Resort in Islamorada offers 114 rooms and direct access to a private beach. Guests can choose from three dining venues: Tides Beachside Bar, Drift on the Beach, and Coccoloba. The property features a putting course for golf enthusiasts and pet-friendly perks. Select accommodations, such as the Poolside Cabana Room, include a private pool and patio access, enhancing the resort experience.
With multiple restaurants and a bar set along the beachside, Islander Resort caters to both relaxation and recreation. Its location in the Florida Keys makes it a notable option for those seeking a beachside stay with on-site amenities.
Why it stands out
EMPTYJET lists Islander Resort as an EMPTYJET property for its private beach, multiple dining options, on-site putting course, and pet-friendly approach in Islamorada. The combination of direct beach access and diverse amenities makes it a strong choice for leisure travellers.
Key facts
- Keys
- 114 rooms
- Check-in / out
- 16:00 / 11:00
- Pets
- allowed
- Type
- Beach, Golf, Family
Amenities
Verified 19 Aug 2026Activities
- Private beach — a private beach
- Beach access — evidence: a private beach
- On-site golf course — a putting course
Dining
- Multiple restaurants — Tides Beachside Bar; Drift on the Beach; Coccoloba
- Bar — Tides Beachside Bar! Set along Islander Resort’s beachside
Policies
- Pet friendly — evidence: pet-friendly perks
Rooms
- Rooms with private pool — Poolside Cabana Room with King bed and patio access
Dining
Verified 19 Aug 2026Beach
Verified 19 Aug 2026Golf
Verified 19 Aug 2026Awards & affiliations
- American ExpressThe Hotel Collection
- American Express The Hotel Collection
Location
24.9203, -80.6307Sources+
- EMPTYJET seed catalogueSeed4 fields
- Official hotel websiteOfficial17 fields
- Serper (Google Maps data)Places provider2 fields
Collections
More in Islamorada
View allAmara Cay Resort Cheeca Lodge and Spa 
EMPTYJET RecommendCheeca Lodge and Spa
Islamorada · United States
66.9EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100$$$from ~$226 / night- Beach
- Golf
- Wellness
Three Waters Resort and Marina, a Tribute Portfolio Resort EMPTYJET RecommendThree Waters Resort and Marina, a Tribute Portfolio Resort
Islamorada · United States
78.8EMPTYJETEMPTYJET Consensus score out of 100Price on request- couples
- families